Please register or login to continue

Register Login

Fireborne Maiden - Part 2 Reviews

apemann
Andy (Formerly Apemann) gave a rating of 3

I really wanted to enjoy your story... but you lost my concentration with your tedious and repetitive and excruciatingly tiresome description of her work with the ball in paragraphs two and three. This is definitely a case of far too much information for information's sake. There are other examples throughout your work, which really detracts from your story, which is a real pity. You could have covered almost all of those two paragraphs in half-a-dozen sentences without detriment to your story.

May I suggest a thorough re-read of both parts and some judicious editing to make the whole more palatable and reader-friendly? It's a good piece of work that has been somewhat damaged (not ruined!) by a dose of verbosity taking over in places. It is not irredeemable :-)

0
Michael T Burr
Michael T Burr Andy: Thanks for the unvarnished review. I am curious. Did you read part 1 of this story? Also did you get past the section you suggest is tedious?
-Michael
Author -
Michael T Burr
Michael T Burr I took your comments to heart and did some work to tighten the section. However, please note that Part 2 is not intended to stand on its own, and I've added a warning to make this clearer. The only reason it exists as a separate part is that the Shortstories101 system has a word count limit. I hope a 500-word section, arbitrarily selected from the middle, isn't the basis for judging a 20,000-word novella. Thanks again for the feedback.
Author -
Andy (Formerly Apemann)
Andy (Formerly Apemann) You must have missed my comment "May I suggest a thorough re-read of BOTH parts.." :-)

I have read both parts again since you've edited them and find them somewhat more palatable, so well done for taking advice on board. I hope you'll continue with this narrative to its conclusion: as it stands it's a bit of a tease only! :-)
Reviewer -

Please login or register to review this story.