Please register or login to continue

Register Login

"My Daughter Knelt Down in Front of a Train" Reviews

2 reviews have given an average rating of 3 out of 5 Stars
AaronTheRocker
AaronTheRocker gave a rating of 5

Damn. These topics are always tough because we want there to be a system or way to go about serious and complicated issues like this, but it isn't a one-size-fits-all. There is a way though to dig deeper into how this works and became.

Ask questions. That is the most important tool of all for conquering issues.

Pertaining to this specific case (and this can go for any) some questions (in my line perceiving the conversation) to ask would be,
When did you start thinking this way? Is it a reoccurring obstacle in your daily life? Have you ever talked about it with someone? Has it been discussed with parents or friends and family members? When you see yourself or imagine yourself, are you someone different? What do you think a boy/man or girl/woman is? Does believing or thinking you are who you are make you feel better or does it suppress other feelings and thoughts?

We all recognize mental health as a component to this because, oddly enough, when depression, anxiety and isolation became the norm in our society so did the idea of "gender theory". With that there seems to be an attack on biology as if that is what is the issue- the realities of the human structure and life because that is a set of logic being denied.

So other questions to ask as a whole for this concept would be,
Is the correlation the causation? How did this come about? Why is transgenderism practice and acceptance more widespread through modern generations compared to previous? Why is that some US states have higher capita rates of transgender individuals compared to others? Is the change in education curriculum encouraging students? How much is psychological to biological? Is it more so societal "trend" and not just who a person is biologically and psychologically? Why are some schools and states taking children away from parents and "prescribing" them therapy, treatments and surgeries without parental consent or knowledge?

My main issue is the arrogance, narrow-minded, arguementative and toxicity of how its being talked and treated. I know there can't be a wrong question, but there can be a wrong outcome. So far in our efforts of conveying ideas and reaching some sort of resolution, no matter how big or small, isn’t working. We must tread tediously on the subject. This isn’t a math theory being debated or discussed about. This is human life.

1
Friendthebluesheep
Friend gave a rating of 1

Just would like you to know that my friend killed himself because he couldn't get the gender affirming care he needed. My first online friend almost died by overdosing several times because instead of using the name he asked to be called his parents wouldn't listen to him and kept calling him his deadname, I have no idea if hes even alive today. One of my classmates tried to drown herself because no matter what she did she she still felt like people only saw her as a boy. I’ve had a few close calls of my own because my parents prioritized my birth gender over my life. Calling the kid in this story his name and allowing him to start hormones didn't save him but I doubt its what killed him, from experience and being around all kinds of trans people I'm sure it only kept him with us a little bit longer. Using his tragic death to make it harder for other trans people to survive is evil and unforgivable, of both you and his mother.

1
Thomas Ray
Thomas Ray As the mother said in the video, "my daughter wasn't a boy trapped in a boy's body. She had mental health issues."

I'm sorry about your friends. I can't imagine your pain.

When someone hates themselves because they don't feel at home in their body, and they feel disgust when they see themselves in the mirror, that must be agonizing. Every single day, that must be painful.
It's also painful to feel like no one sees the real you.

Where I think we disagree is that I don't think the solution is to tell them that that disgust, self-loathing and despair, is the feeling they should affirm and follow.

So often the problem is not these children's bodies, it's their mental health problems. And when they get their breasts cut off-- or worse, are castrated and steralized-- they realize that their body was never the problem, and now they've lost so much potential happiness because they were told the LIE that you can find happiness by changing their body.

They're told that lie, then realize they're still the same depressed person, only now they're worse off!

And then they kneel down in front of a train.

Do you see what I'm trying to say?

What about the ones who regret it? Why don't they matter???
Author -
Thomas Ray
Thomas Ray Also, did you watch the video?

Because if you did I don't know how you can call the mother evil and unforgivable.

She's HEARTBROKEN. a heartbreak just like you've experienced.

Don't dismiss her pain. Don't dismiss her experience. Don't label her as evil when she's just a mother who had her daughter taken from her piece by piece.

Don't dismiss that.
Author -
Thomas Ray
Thomas Ray Sorry if I got too heated just now. I'm just so sick of people ignoring this side of the story.
Author -
Friend
Friend You don't know if he wasn't trans. His mother says that because of her opinions and you know what, my mom would say the same crap if I died because I wouldn't be able to fight it. Heartbroken people can still be disgusting for weaponizing a tragic death. "Gender ideology" is the only reason so many of my friends are still alive to this day. Transphobia and stuff like this is what killed others. Do you know how overwhelming waking up and realizing everyone you know thinks theres something horribly wrong with you is? Looking at the news and learning that once again it is being made even harder to get the help you need? Going online and hearing that another trans person was murdered when walking home for "looking" trans?? Even if we were given all the care and mental help we needed that is terrifying, no matter how mush we pass as cis we will be hated. Some people can't handle that. Yes I don't think little kids should have the surgeries, I don't think that should even happen until they are 18 but I do think that kids should be able to have the correct puberties the same time every other kid goes through theres because I've watched it save lives several times. Yes they should get mental help, they should go to a gender therapist and normal therapists and learn how to manage their health, but saying its gender ideology that killed this boy when it was most likely the overwhelming transphobia like this is just wrong. Stop using this tragic death to make a difficult road for kids ever more impossible, he deserves to rest, not be used as a weapon against his own people.
Reviewer -
Friend
Reviewer -
Friend
Friend aw shit I meant 90% don't regret I'm so sorry my writing is shit😭
Reviewer -
Friend
Friend also only like a 10% number of people regret it and the detranstion rate is even smaller. sorry about that mix up
Reviewer -
Thomas Ray
Thomas Ray So, the mother was speaking out specifically against making affirmation a REQUIREMENT for parents.

This mother is speaking out against law requiring parents to affirm, affirm, affirm. Her daughter was physically taken from her, and she was accused of abuse!

That's the problem here specifically.
Author -
Thomas Ray
Thomas Ray She's not weaponizing a tragic death, she's trying to prevent more like it.
Author -
Thomas Ray
Thomas Ray I also think it's beyond arrogant for you to assume you know more about that daughter's experience than her own mother.

You, a complete stranger, are saying "no, you don't know the real reason your daughter died. The real reason was because you didn't affirm her soon enough."
Author -
Friend
Friend I'm not going to argue with you Thomas. I just hope you understand the people you are hurting. Have a nice day.
Reviewer -
Thomas Ray
Thomas Ray I don't want to argue either. I just hope you understand that it's not possible to deny biology without paying a huge price.
I hope you have a good day too.
Author -
Thomas Ray
Thomas Ray Also, here's a longer (11 minute) video explaining the story of Yaeli and her mother. Just in case you want to learn more about it.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=M58PqUjezdM&bpctr=1687891315
Author -

Please login or register to review this story.