Please register or login to continue

Register Login

matthewmeager's Avatar

matthewmeager

matthewmeager is from US United States • 29 y/o

Reviews Received

apemann
Andy (Formerly Apemann) reviewed The Time Travellers

An interesting idea that was, unfortunately, poorly executed. Trying to tell such a 'big' story in so few words was always going to be a big ask. You would have been better served, perhaps, by working your story into several chapters or parts, which would have allowed you to expand on your ideas in greater detail.

0
apemann
Andy (Formerly Apemann) reviewed CONCRETE ANGEL

Again, as with your other work. you ignore the basic rules of writing, which spoils everything you do. This could have been so much better had you taken the time to work on it properly and correcting all of the many errors that are strewn throughout the piece.

0
lemonslice
lemonslice reviewed CONCRETE ANGEL

Sorry, Matthew, but this is dire. You need to adhere to common grammar and punctuation rules if you want people to take your writing seriously.

1
apemann
Andy (Formerly Apemann) reviewed SCHOOL'S BATHROOM MIRRORS

Thank you for your story. There is the basis here for a good story, but your rushed approach to your writing and the lack of attention to basic detail (punctuation, spelling, grammar) spoil your work. More care and attention will help you write a better story and also present it in a more acceptable and pleasing manner. The use of capitals is horrible.

0
lemonslice
lemonslice reviewed SCHOOL'S BATHROOM MIRRORS

You don't have a story here yet, Matthew. It's mainly a collection of scattered ideas, loosely strung together with poor grammar. I'd recommend you took a more sensible approach to your writing if you want to find an audience for it.

0
ashwin
ashwin reviewed CONCRETE ANGEL

It has an impact, for sure.
But, several glaring mistakes could be found in this piece.
Kindly get a copy editor in place; every writer needs an editor, remember.

0
AaronTheRocker
AaronTheRocker reviewed SCHOOL'S BATHROOM MIRRORS

Good grammar makes a good story. Bad grammar makes a bad story and this is bad grammar. Not saying it has to be perfect, but some things just bother readers especially when it comes to punctuation, proper nouns, spelling, all that good stuff.
I like the idea, but I believe it was poorly executed.

0
Kaleighishappy
Kat reviewed SCHOOL'S BATHROOM MIRRORS

I think that though you do need to work on the grammar and punctuation and sentencing, there is a great idea implanted in your writing. I suggest making this the prompt for a new story.
You could start out with the boy not thinking that the story was true, and entering the abandoned bathroom. This way the reader is still creeped out and worried for the main character.
You could also use an age for the boy (both of them), and tell why the boy in the mirror is first off in the mirror and second whh he skipped his classes.
Great work, can't wait to hear more!

0