Please register or login to continue

Register Login

IanG's Avatar

IanG

IanG is from GB United Kingdom • 61 y/o

Reviews Given

Ghost Story by SJD ❤

Please take this as constructive criticism, as this is good for such a young writer.

Why does he ask "did someone live here twenty years ago?" He would more likely say "who lived here before us?" He must know they didn't build the house themselves, and if not then obviously someone lived there before them. The question is who were they? Mum could say in reply exactly when the last occupants left.

0 Edit Delete
Miss Jarron and Her Cat by Durandal

There are a few spelling mistakes here, for instance 'fir' should be 'fur'. Fir is a coniferous tree. Having said that, it was a nice twist at the end. There's certainly some truth in the idea that he stood a better chance befriending the cat than chasing it.

0 Edit Delete
Under the Stairs by AaronTheRocker

Try writing 'dad was upstairs working on his computer' rather than 'the computer.' If Mom is in the kitchen working on a computer its a different one than Dad is using.

You portray a child's emotions plausibly, and I like the detail about the spiders webs moving. Perhaps you could've had them find out later if someone died prematurely in the house, or if a previous occupant had a scary experience there.

1 Edit Delete
Before You Pull the Trigger... Pt. 2 by 505771

You're drawing readers in by describing their sadness but not yet explaining the reason for it. With 'Anyway Back' there should be a lower case 'b' in 'back,' but more practice should fix issues like that.

2 Edit Delete
Quarantine by MyThoughts

If we all got upset every time something bad happened in the world, we would loose our sanity. You're not a bad person if you can't tackle every issue. Dealing with the present lockdown is a new experience even for adults. Is it any wonder a lot of people find it hard to handle. Don't break the law, this lockdown won't last forever, it can't or economies all over the world will crumble. Surely no government run by sentinent adults will allow that.

I hope things improve for you soon.

0 Edit Delete
The Beach by Storm

You could've made more of your narrator's reaction to the death of his uncle. Did he change his attitude to the beach due to that? If so, did he draw on memories of better times and so begin to enjoy it again? Perhaps he realised that nowhere is ever entirely safe and if the sea hadn't taken his uncle then something else might have.

1 Edit Delete
The Crow As Animal Totem by Aquarius

The crow family are highly intelligent birds, some species use twigs to extract grubs from tree bark. People living close to nature must've noticed that. I think that's why they were revered by pre-industrial peoples.

0 Edit Delete
A Hybrid's Life by Ilovepugs

If you broke it up into paragraphs it would be easier to follow. Some sentences, such as the final one, could be broken down into shorter ones. That said, formatting can be lost when publishing a story online. It happened to the latest one I published here, but I've edited and corrected that now.

0 Edit Delete